One of the things you notice quickly when editing books is a lot of "Original" ideas aren't. The contributor may think it's new and different but after having read the same idea many times--it ain't. So, the difference is in the telling. In Tales From Dry Gulch one story deals with being buried alive. That's been done before. But her story was different in that a coffin salesman was demonstrating the features on his coffin and ends up getting buried. Well, the criminal extorts money to dig the guy back up, Then he tries to kill him and bury him again. Not to despair, the alien piano player comes to the rescue. The crook, well he's already a cheater at cards, so the piano player is not looking kindly on the fellow.
That's a different buried alive than someone like Poe would do. I liked the story. But the author didn't think it just involved being buried alive. Alas, too many stories that come in are little more ideas. Touches like the guy cheats at cards, too aren't included.
Likewise, an army of hundreds of undead riders roaring into town is not particularly new, either. But if someone worked a card cheat into the story, then I might be more kindly disposed toward it.
As regular readers of this blog may have noticed, I tend to rail on editing things a lot when I'm actively reading for something as I am now. When Six Guns Straight From Hell 3 is wrapped up then I'll likely fixate on garbage and Tucson's mediocre restaurants.
Speaking of cheating at cards, the Angel Mabel [Fallen Angel] has certain powers. But she wouldn't dream of cheating at poker. She thinks card cheats are the lowest form of scum on earth--from an angel cast out of heaven and sort of banished to hell.
By the way, I hardly ever see card cheat or stories about gamblers. I don't know why.